California Judge: Unusual Ruling in Lead Paint Case - Alliance
January 6, 2014

California Judge: Unusual Ruling in Lead Paint Case

Written by Alliance Environmental

We’ve been covering the lead paint lawsuits in California for a while now. In December, Santa Clara County Superior Court Judge James Kleinberg ruled against paint manufacturers and in favor of Santa Clara, Alameda, Los Angeles, Monterey, San Mateo, Solano and Ventura counties, and the cities of Oakland, San Diego and San Francisco. He also ordered the paint makers to pay $1.1 billion to fund lead paint removal in approximately 5 million California homes.

But Judge Kleinberg’s ruling was a very unusual one, not just for the amount of the fines, but for the ruling itself. Paint companies have in the past been very successful in fighting lawsuits concerning lead poisoning from lead paint used in homes.

Over the last 25 years, as many as 50 lawsuits have been brought against paint manufacturers for lead poisoning and only one was ever decided in favor of the Plaintiffs–in Rhode Island. That decision was later reversed on appeal.

Why did those lawsuits fail where this one succeeded? Past suits were dismissed because although lead paint was present in a home, which layer of paint contributed to the lead poisoning could not be determined. They also failed when judges ruled that the cases could only be brought by individuals who had suffered direct harm, not by governments claiming lead paint to be a “public nuisance.”

Lead paint makers have argued that they did not sell a harmful product deliberately, so they should not be liable, claiming that they did not know the lead in paint was dangerous when they were selling it.

What was the difference in the latest case? Paul Elias of the Associated Press reports:

“‘In the 1920s, scientists from the Paint Manufacturers Association reported that lead paint used on the interiors of homes would deteriorate, and that lead dust resulting from this deterioration would poison children and cause serious injury,’ the judge wrote in his 110-page decision. ‘It was accepted by the medical and scientific community before the 1950s, as reflected in literature from as early as 1894, that lead paint was a significant cause of childhood lead poisoning.'” Nanaimo Daily News

At Alliance Environmental Group, we will continue to watch as the appeal process for this ruling progresses through the courts, but we know that lead paint is still dangerous, still out there, still poisoning babies and children and even more harmful than previously believed. We are ready and eager to participate in making California homes healthy and safe.

Related

Other Environmental Posts

View Category
May 18, 2022
-
Alliance Environmental
ALLIANCE NEWS – NEWSLETTER 23
The month of May is dedicated to National Wildfire Awareness Month. Knowing how to prevent and be prepared for wildfires is crucial to the health and safety of all. Over the last few years, every corner of this country has been affected by devastating wildfires. According to the National Interagency Fire Center, 45,518 wildfires burned…
April 13, 2022
-
Alliance Environmental
ALLIANCE NEWS – NEWSLETTER 22
Spring is in full bloom, and Easter is around the corner. As we enter the second quarter of the year, we are starting to see a return to life as we had once known. More people are dining out. Travel has seen an increase as people go on vacation, and retail shops see an increase…
March 8, 2022
-
Alliance Environmental
ALLIANCE NEWS – NEWSLETTER 21
We at Alliance Environmental Group would like to acknowledge the women who continue to break down barriers and excel in all industries but specifically those who play key roles either in the field or positions of management and leadership. March helps us celebrate these phenomenal women with the celebration of International Women’s Day and the…
January 6, 2022
-
Alliance Environmental
ALLIANCE NEWS – NEWSLETTER 20
Here’s wishing you a wonderful start to 2022 and a prosperous year ahead. With a new year, we are afforded with the opportunity for us to focus on ensuring safety while effectively addressing indoor air quality and the need for us as a community to maintain clean and sanitary environments at home, school, workplace, or…
December 27, 2021
-
Alliance Environmental
The HOA & Manager’s Guide to Mold in Apartment Complexes
Winter is here and that means one thing when it comes to mold: it’s time for it to grow and spread. Since mold prefers areas with high humidity and moisture, winter can pose an issue for apartment and condo complexes in particular as it is harder for these spaces to regulate the condensation that happens…
December 20, 2021
-
Alliance Environmental
Dangers of Lead in Children’s Toys and the Home
Protecting families from health risks is something everybody wants to do, and within many homes, there are still risks of lead poisoning for children and adults alike. Lead has been banned in many household products and children’s toys, but it is still a problem that can affect families. The holiday season is a big time…
December 17, 2021
-
Alliance Environmental
Your Guide to Prepping Facilities for Winter
When we think of winterizing, we often simply think about preparing for the colder temperatures, ensuring that pipes don’t burst and the like. But proper winterization is about more than inspecting pipes. It’s about improving the heating efficiency in your facilities, increasing safety and workflows, and ensuring that the occupants are comfortable and content throughout…
December 13, 2021
-
Alliance Environmental
Understanding Asbestos Risks During Winter Renovations
The holiday and winter seasons are a great time to get together with family and friends, however, it is also a great time to get some home renovations done while off from work. These renovations are often small, but they can still come with risks if working on an older home that could contain asbestos.…
December 2, 2021
-
Alliance Environmental
ALLIANCE NEWS – NEWSLETTER 19
December has dawned upon us, and we have entered the final stretch of what can be summarized as a tumultuous year. The holiday season is here, and as we look back on the past year, we can reflect on how we have had to adapt to pandemic life and living in this new normal way…
November 2, 2021
-
Alliance Environmental
ALLIANCE NEWS – NEWSLETTER 18
We have just commenced with the penultimate month of the year, and we have a lot to be thankful for. November marks National Gratitude month. As we move ahead with our daily lives and routines, we should be reminded of the importance of Thanksgiving and giving back. In chronological order, November 11 is Veterans Day.…
View Category